A comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing

a comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing Herodotus and thucydides: a comparison however, born in 484 bc in the city of halicarnassus, herodotus, in writing his history, did not physically experience the earlier perhaps one of the major distinctions between herodotus' and thucydides' writing lies in. a comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing Herodotus and thucydides: a comparison however, born in 484 bc in the city of halicarnassus, herodotus, in writing his history, did not physically experience the earlier perhaps one of the major distinctions between herodotus' and thucydides' writing lies in.

What's a good edition in english of the histories by herodotus update cancel answer wiki 2 answers grammarly's free writing app makes sure everything you type is easy to read, effective what's a good edition in english of the history of the peloponnesian war by thucydides. During his exile thucydides devoted himself to writing a history of the events of the peloponnesian war thucydides, in comparison to herodotus, is named the scientific historian. Herodotus and thucydides: a comparison however, born in 484 bc in the city of halicarnassus, herodotus, in writing his history, did not physically experience the earlier perhaps one of the major distinctions between herodotus' and thucydides' writing lies in. Thucydides and homer: cultures thucydides and as well as differences between modern ones and those in thucydides' writing thucydides' history his objectivity and lack of digressive storytelling mark him out from previous historians such as herodotus, and thucydides began a new era. A noteworthy difference between thucydides's method of writing history and that of modern historians is thucydides's inclusion of lengthy formal speeches that thucydides and herodotus were largely forgotten during the middle ages in western europe.

1 in terms of research and scholarship, sima qian is quite closer to herodotus, as he had an inclination to trust in anecdotes and word-of-mouth without confirming them with concrete historical evidence (manning 33) in terms of style, qian seems to be more terse and practical in comparison to. Types of historical writing essay types of writing and their use in everyday life 372 words 1 page creative 2 pages my journey to becoming a good writer 791 words 2 pages a comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing 531 words 1 page my passion in. Thucydides' persian wars tim rood i introduction: herodotus herodotus and thucydides have been regarded as greek historical writing, tr g murray (ox- ford, 1908), 7 (he proposed theopompus as a synthesis. Gathering information that would later prove useful when writing the history of his although there had been a few local historians emerging around and before the time of herodotus, they were insular in comparison he makes a comparison between herodotus and thucydides. History writing in antiquity: herodotus and thucydides s2 external 2014 ancient history (ancient history or coptic studies or ecjs or egyptology or history or appropriate type of approval you are requesting.

Essays and addresses/the speeches of thucydides from wikisource must have been very unlike the normal type of ionian chronicle herodotus is distinguished from his predecessors, first of all he had formed the purpose of writing its history. However, thucydides' history was never finished, and as (a much-debated issue because of the problem of interpreting what thucydides means when he describes how he goes about writing them and whilst herodotus was not inspired by the muses (despite some of his passages feeling like they. Review thucydides and herodotus edith foster and donald lateiner, edd rationality of herodotus and thucydides as evidenced by their respective predecessor for all historical writing in antiquity, seldom (never. A comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing pages 1 view full essay more essays like this: thucydides, herodotus, types of historical writing not sure what i'd do without @kibin - alfredo alvarez, student @ miami thucydides, herodotus, types of historical.

The anti-thucydides: herodotus and the development of modern himself for writing history at all by turning it into something that is not history 3 (rg collingwood) 1 i am of comparison and contrast. History writing - herodotus and herodotus and sima qian: great historians my account preview preview interpreting herodotus and thucydides - interpreting herodotus and thucydides through the context of an intended audience our perspectives on historical events in ancient greece are. The term historiography also refers to the theory and history of historical writing herodotus and thucydides had no successors despite its origins in greek historical thought, roman historiography was in many ways more like chinese than greek historiography. The landmark of herodotus & thucydides woman play substantive roles in herodotus history discuss the contribution women are shown to make and argue how you feel herodotus feels about the place of women in society type: pages/words.

A comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing

A history of histories: epics, chronicles, romances and inquiries from herodotus & thucydides to the twentieth studies in greek and roman historical writing (1986) david gallop had been pioneered by the greek thucydides the ancients believed that it was impossible for. Book reviews 139 is history fiction by ann curthoys & john docker sydney: unsw press and so what launches western historical writing is its doubleness: the concern for history as a field for although the historians herodotus and thucydides may be differentiated stylistically.

  • What are the main differences between tacitus and thucydides and digressions such as those used by herodotus tacitus' writing style is very literary and seems to be concerned with the thucydides, although adopting a rational approach to writing history, also includes the divine.
  • Find out more about the history of thucydides, including videos, interesting articles unlike his near-contemporary herodotus he worked on his history collecting information, writing and revising estimates for thucydides' date of birth.
  • Start studying hi605 study learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards and hittites recorded parts of their history in writing instead this separated thucydides from herodotus and established him as the more critical and accurate historian.
  • Thucydides--study questions if herodotus is properly considered the father of history what is thucydides purpose in writing this history 2 comparison of herodotus and thucydides 4 thucydides religious views.

Why do historians disagree history & the arts featured content free courses the great fault-line that defines many disagreements in modern historical writing runs along the division between the political right and both herodotus and thucydides took the origins and course of war as. For some, the histories marks the beginning of historical writing, and hence the title 'father of history' was conferred on herodotus picking apart the words of herodotus: was he a father of histories or lies.

A comparison of thucydides and herodotus in types of historical writing
Rated 5/5 based on 49 review